Best Eyeliner: Your Guide To Finding The Perfect Eye-Defining Tool

Dr. Domenic Monahan 19 Aug 2025

Finding the perfect eyeliner can really feel like a quest, can't it? You want something that just works, something that makes your eyes pop without a fuss. It's not just about drawing a line; it's about finding that one product that truly brings your vision for your look to life, whether it's a subtle enhancement or a dramatic statement.

So, too it's almost, many of us have faced the smudged wing or the faded line by midday. It’s frustrating, to say the least. We all wish for that ideal liner that stays put, looks fantastic, and maybe, just maybe, is simple to put on. That search for the "best" often leads us down a rabbit hole of options, from pencils to liquids, and everything in between.

That's precisely why we've put in the time, really. Our team, you know, has explored and tried out a whole lot of popular eyeliners, over eighty different ones, actually, to really discover what stands out. We wanted to make sense of all the choices and point you toward the ones that consistently deliver. This way, you get to skip some of the guesswork and find your next favorite eye-defining product.

What's the Deal with "Best Eyeliner"?
Types of Eyeliner: Finding Your Match
What Makes an Eyeliner Truly Great?
Expert Picks and What They Mean for You
Tips for Getting the Most From Your Eyeliner
Common Eyeliner Questions Answered
Making Your Best Choice

What's the Deal with "Best Eyeliner"?

When someone says "best eyeliner," what do they really mean? Well, it's a bit like saying "best car" – it really depends on what you need it for, doesn't it? For some, the "best" means it absolutely will not budge, even through a long day. For others, it’s about how easy it is to draw a clean, crisp line. And then, there are those who just want something simple for a quick everyday touch.

Our research, which involved trying out more than 80 popular eyeliners, showed us that "best" is very personal. What's perfect for a dramatic winged look might be too much for a subtle tightline. So, when we talk about the "best," we're considering a range of needs, from how long it stays on to how simple it is to put on, and even how it feels on your skin. We also looked at how easy it is to take off before bed, which is, you know, pretty important too.

It's about finding what works best for your unique style and daily routine. We've certainly tried to narrow things down to help you avoid the guesswork. Whether you’re an eyeliner fan who wants to try a lot of different formulas or someone just looking for one reliable option, understanding the different types and what makes them good is a great starting point.

Types of Eyeliner: Finding Your Match

There are quite a few kinds of eyeliner out there, and each one offers something a little different. Knowing what each type does can really help you pick the right one for your desired effect. We've explored everything from liquids to gels and pencils, and even pots, to give you a good idea of what's available.

Liquid Liners for Sharp Looks

Liquid eyeliners are, in a way, the go-to for really precise lines and sharp wings. They come in little pots with a brush, or in pen-like applicators that are often easier to handle. These are what you typically reach for when you want a very defined, clean look that really stands out. Many of the "best liquid liners" we've seen are celebrated for their intense color and smooth flow.

Applying liquid liner can be a bit of a learning curve for some, it's true. But once you get the hang of it, the results are pretty striking. They tend to dry quickly, which helps prevent smudging once they're on. And, you know, for creating that perfect, crisp line, there's hardly anything better. Some of the ones we looked at were definitely praised by makeup artists for their ability to create those flawless, long-lasting lines.

Gel Pots and Creams for Smooth Glides

Gel eyeliners, usually found in little pots, are applied with a separate brush. They offer a lovely balance between the precision of a liquid and the blendability of a pencil. You can create super sharp lines, or you can smudge them out a little for a softer, smoky look. They are, in some respects, very versatile.

These formulas are often quite long-wearing and can be pretty intense in color. Many people find them easier to work with than liquid liners, as they offer a bit more playtime before they set. We've seen many professionals and editors pick these for their smooth application and how well they stay put throughout the day. They're a really good option for someone who wants control and a rich color payoff.

Pencil Eyeliners for Everyday Ease

Pencil eyeliners are, arguably, the most common and the easiest to use for most people. They are great for beginners and for quick, everyday makeup. You can get them in traditional sharpenable forms or as retractable pencils. They're fantastic for lining the water line or for a soft line along the lash line.

While they might not give you the super sharp wing of a liquid, they are wonderful for a softer, more natural look. Some pencil liners are designed to be really creamy, making them easy to glide on without pulling the skin. They're also often quite simple to smudge for a smoky effect. For an everyday pencil eyeliner that stays on and is easy to remove, these are often a top choice.

Kohl Liners for Smoky Effects

Kohl liners are a special kind of pencil eyeliner, really. They are typically much softer and more intensely pigmented, designed for creating those classic, smudgy, smoky eye looks. They're often used for lining the inner rim of the eye, or for creating a dramatic, lived-in look.

The beauty of kohl is how easily it blends out. It gives you a much softer, diffused line compared to a crisp liquid. We've certainly seen these mentioned among the "best kohl" options for anyone wanting to achieve that effortlessly cool, smudged effect. They're not about precision, but about depth and drama, in a way.

What Makes an Eyeliner Truly Great?

So, what exactly puts an eyeliner in the "best of the best" category? It's not just one thing, you know. It's a combination of features that make it a joy to use and reliable throughout your day. We’ve certainly looked at many aspects during our testing of over 80 different eyeliners.

One very important factor is how long it lasts. Does it stay put all day, or does it start to fade and smudge after just a few hours? The best eyeliners are often those that resist smudging, creasing, and flaking, keeping your look fresh from morning till night. This is a big concern for many people, especially if they have oily eyelids or live in humid climates.

Then there's the application experience. Is it smooth and easy to apply, or does it tug and skip? A good eyeliner should glide on effortlessly, whether it's a liquid brush or a creamy pencil. The pigment should be rich and opaque in one swipe, so you don't have to keep going over the same spot. This makes a huge difference in how quickly and neatly you can put on your makeup, honestly.

Also, consider the finish. Do you want a matte look, or something with a bit of metallic sheen? The "best" options offer a range of finishes, from deep blacks to bright colors, and even some shimmery metallics. This variety lets you play around and match your eyeliner to your mood or your outfit, which is pretty fun, you know.

Finally, and this is sometimes overlooked, how easy is it to remove? While you want it to stay on all day, you also want it to come off without a struggle at night. The ideal eyeliner strikes a good balance, staying put when you need it to, but dissolving easily with your preferred makeup remover. This helps keep your delicate eye area happy and healthy.

Expert Picks and What They Mean for You

When we talk about the "best eyeliners," it's worth noting that many of our insights come from what makeup artists and beauty editors really like. These are the people who try hundreds of products, so their opinions carry a lot of weight, you know. They’re constantly working with different formulas and seeing how they perform in various situations.

For instance, we've heard celebrity makeup artists and Vogue editors often mention brands like Rare Beauty, MAC Cosmetics, and Huda Beauty when discussing their top choices. This isn't to say these are the *only* good ones, but they're often cited for their consistent quality and innovative formulas. MAC Cosmetics, for example, has a long history of reliable products, and their eyeliners are frequently praised for their intense color and staying power.

Rare Beauty, on the other hand, might be highlighted for its user-friendly applicators and inclusive shade ranges, making it a great option for people of all skill levels. Huda Beauty is often celebrated for its bold pigments and unique textures, appealing to those who love to experiment with their looks. These examples show that "best" can mean different things to different experts, based on what they value most in an eyeliner.

What this means for you is that these expert-backed choices can be a really good starting point. They've already been put through their paces by people who know makeup inside and out. So, if you're feeling a bit overwhelmed by the choices, looking at what the pros use can definitely help narrow things down. It's a way to benefit from someone else's extensive testing, in a way.

Tips for Getting the Most From Your Eyeliner

Once you've picked out what you think might be the best eyeliner for you, knowing a few simple tricks can really make a difference in your application and how long it lasts. These tips can help you get that perfect line, whether you're a beginner or just looking to refine your technique.

First off, a steady hand is pretty important. If you find your hand shaking a bit, try resting your elbow on a table or flat surface. This can give you a lot more control and help you draw a smoother line. Some people also find it easier to draw a few small dashes along the lash line and then connect them, rather than trying to draw one long, continuous line. This can make the process feel a lot less daunting, you know.

For liquid and gel liners, a good trick is to start with a thin line and then build it up. It’s always easier to add more product than to take it away. If you’re aiming for a winged look, try drawing a small dot where you want the wing to end, and then connect it back to your lash line. This can help ensure both wings are somewhat symmetrical, which is, you know, often the trickiest part.

If you're using a pencil eyeliner and want it to last longer, try setting it with a little bit of eyeshadow in a similar color. Just gently pat the eyeshadow over the liner with a small brush. This can help lock it in place and prevent smudging, especially if you have oily eyelids. It's a simple step that can make a big difference, honestly.

For those who struggle with smudging under the eyes, particularly with kohl or pencil liners, a little bit of translucent setting powder applied lightly under the lower lash line before applying liner can help. This creates a barrier that can absorb oils and keep your liner from migrating. It's a pretty effective little secret, in a way.

And remember, practice really does make perfect. Don't get discouraged if your first few attempts aren't exactly what you hoped for. Just keep trying, and you'll soon find the technique that works best for you and your chosen eyeliner. You can always learn more about eyeliner techniques on our site, too.

Common Eyeliner Questions Answered

We often hear similar questions when people are trying to find their perfect eyeliner. Let's tackle a few of them that people often ask, to help clear up some common uncertainties.

What kind of eyeliner is easiest to use?

For most people, pencil eyeliners are considered the easiest to use. They offer a lot of control and are forgiving if you make a small mistake. Retractable pencils, in particular, don't even need sharpening, which makes them very convenient. They're great for beginners or for quick, everyday application, honestly.

Which eyeliner stays on all day without smudging?

When it comes to staying power, liquid and gel eyeliners often perform best. Many formulas are designed to be waterproof or water-resistant, and once they dry, they tend to stay put for hours without smudging or fading. Look for products specifically labeled as "long-wear" or "smudge-proof" if this is your main concern. We've certainly found that many of the expert-recommended options excel in this area.

What's the difference between liquid, gel, and pencil eyeliner?

Liquid eyeliner gives you a very sharp, precise line and an intense color payoff, great for winged looks. Gel eyeliner, which comes in a pot and is applied with a brush, offers a smooth glide, allowing for both sharp lines and easy smudging. Pencil eyeliner is generally softer, easier to apply for beginners, and great for a more natural look or for smudging out. Each type creates a distinct effect, so it really depends on the look you're going for, you know.

Making Your Best Choice

Ultimately, the "best eyeliner" for you is the one that fits your needs, your skill level, and your desired look. We've certainly done a lot of research, exploring over 80 different popular eyeliners, to help narrow down the options. We looked at everything from liquids and gels to pencils and pots, paying attention to what makes them stand out.

Remember, what works for a celebrity makeup artist or a beauty editor might be a great starting point, but your own experience is key. Take your pick between pencils and pots, mattes and metallics, blacks and brights – no matter what, you’re in for a treat with the variety available today. The goal is to find something that helps you make the best of your time and your look.

So, why not give a few different types a try? Perhaps you'll discover a new favorite liquid liner for a sharp wing, or a creamy pencil for an everyday touch. We've narrowed down a list of the best to eliminate some of the guesswork for you. If you're an eyeliner enthusiast, consider adding one of these formulas, or maybe even all of them, to your makeup collection. You can also explore more about top eyeliner brands to find what catches your eye. And for more beauty insights, you might want to visit our beauty tips page too. Happy lining!

The best Android tablets in 2025: the 7 best ones you can buy | Digital

Pastor's Blog - Steve Vera - KING OF KINGS LUTHERAN CHURCH & PRESCHOOL

What Is Your Best?

Veritas Daily